Skip to content
The work Engagements T&L Questions
T&L Custom &Strategic Solutions Book a conversation
Menu
The work Engagements T&L Questions Book a conversation
Back to Blog
November 15, 2026

How to Make Decisions Faster Without Second-Guessing Yourself

T

Tonia Lewis

How to Make Decisions Faster Without Second-Guessing Yourself

You have a decision sitting in front of you right now. Maybe it is a hire, a price change, a partnership, a job offer, or whether to finally end a project that has been draining you for months. You have thought about it in the shower. You have thought about it on the drive home. You have opened the same spreadsheet four times and closed it four times without changing a single number.

The problem is not that you lack information. The problem is that you are treating a small decision like a large one, and a large one like a test of your character. That is how a busy week turns into a week where you got a lot done and moved nothing forward.

If you want to learn how to make decisions faster without becoming reckless, this guide is for you. It is the same set of steps I walk clients through in one-on-one sessions when they are stuck. It is not about trusting your gut blindly or gathering more data. It is about matching your effort to the size of the decision, then committing out loud so you cannot quietly renegotiate with yourself at 11pm.

Why You Are Slow in the First Place

Most people who describe themselves as indecisive are not actually indecisive. They are thorough. They are also carrying three unhelpful habits that make thoroughness expensive.

Habit 1: Blending decisions with identity

You are not choosing between two vendors. You are asking whether you are the kind of leader who makes smart choices. That is a much heavier question, and it never resolves, because there is no data set that can confirm your worth as a leader.

Habit 2: Debating the same decision at three different energy levels

You think about it when you are fresh, then again when you are tired, then again when you are anxious. You take the tired verdict seriously. You should not. A decision reviewed at 9am and re-litigated at 10pm is not twice reviewed. It is reviewed once and then worried about.

Habit 3: Waiting for certainty that will not arrive

Certainty feels like the responsible prerequisite. It is usually just a delay tactic dressed in a nice suit. For most business and career decisions, you will have somewhere between 60 and 80 percent of what you would ideally want to know. The remaining 20 to 40 percent only becomes available after you move.

The goal is not to make the perfect decision. It is to make a good decision on time and stay honest about what you learn.

Step 1: Sort the Decision by Reversibility and Cost

Before you do any thinking, classify the decision. Two questions. Can I undo this, and what does undoing it cost me? That is it.

Example: you are deciding whether to test a new pricing tier with a small group of clients. That is reversible. It costs you a few uncomfortable emails. You could decide this in ten minutes.

Example: you are deciding whether to sell a minority stake in your business to fund growth. That is close to irreversible, and the cost of unwinding it is high. That deserves a documented process and a week of reflection.

Most people invert this. They agonize for three weeks over a software subscription and then sign a two-year office lease in an afternoon because the broker was friendly and the light was nice.

Decision typeTime budgetWho to involveHow to close it
Reversible, low cost10 minutesNobodyPick the option with the fastest feedback loop
Reversible, moderate cost1 dayOne person who will be affectedSet a review date and a trip wire to reverse it
Hard to reverse, moderate cost3 to 5 daysTwo people with different perspectivesWrite a one-page decision memo
Hard to reverse, high cost1 to 2 weeksTwo or three people, one of whom disagreesDecision memo plus a pre-mortem plus a written record

Notice the totals. A low-cost reversible decision gets ten minutes. A high-cost irreversible one gets up to two weeks. Nothing gets six months of background anxiety. If you follow the table honestly, you will find that the majority of what keeps you up at night is in the top two rows.

Step 2: Name the Decision in One Sentence

Vague decisions cannot be closed. Write the decision as a single sentence in this form: I am deciding whether to X by date Y, and I will judge success by Z.

Not useful: "I need to figure out my hiring situation."

Useful: "I am deciding whether to hire a part-time operations manager by March 14, and I will judge success by whether my own time on admin drops enough to free two client-facing days per week."

That second version gives you something to argue with. It also reveals the real question, which may not be hire or no hire. It might be whether you are willing to give up control over the way the admin gets done. Half of the decisions my clients are stuck on turn out to be a different question once they write the sentence.

One sentence, one decision

If your sentence contains the word "and" joining two choices, split it. "Should I raise prices and restructure my team" is two decisions stacked on top of each other. Decide the first one, live with it for a week, then decide the second.

Step 3: Run a 20 Minute Decision Memo

This is the core ritual. Set a timer for 20 minutes. Open a blank document. Answer these six prompts in plain language, no bullet points, no polish.

  1. The real decision: one sentence, as above.
  2. The three options: include the option of doing nothing. Doing nothing is a real option and it should be judged on its merits, not used as a hiding place.
  3. What matters most here: name the single criterion that outweighs the others. Revenue? Time with your family? Reputation? Learning speed? You get one. Two criteria means no decision.
  4. The best available evidence: what you actually know versus what you are assuming. Flag every assumption with the word "assume."
  5. The cost of waiting: what happens to this decision if you make it 30 days later? Often the answer is "nothing." Sometimes the answer is "the person I want to hire takes another job." That difference should drive your pace.
  6. The decision and the date: pick one and pick a date. Not a range. A date.

Twenty minutes is not enough time to write a beautiful memo, and that is the point. The timer forces you to produce your thinking rather than polish or loop it. If you finish in 14 minutes, you are done early. Do not use the leftover six minutes to reconsider.

Confident businesswoman in a modern office space, embodying success and leadership.

This works especially well for entrepreneurs who have nobody to think out loud with. The document acts as the colleague. Read it back the next morning and you will usually find that the decision has already quietly settled in your mind.

Step 4: Talk to Two People, Not Ten

When you ask ten people what they think, you get ten different frameworks, and then you have a new project: reconciling the frameworks. Choose two people instead.

Choose one person who knows your situation well and cares about you. Choose one person who is smart, has no stake in the outcome, and will disagree with you if they think you are wrong. That second person matters more than people expect.

How to ask so you get useful input

Do not ask "What would you do?" Ask this instead: "Here is my decision and my reasoning. Where is my reasoning weakest?"

That question respects their intelligence, keeps the decision with you, and gets you an actual critique instead of a polite mirror. If a friend only tells you what you want to hear, thank them and adjust your lineup for next time.

Protect against the consensus trap

If both people agree easily and quickly, be suspicious. Either the decision is genuinely obvious, or you framed the memo in a way that made one answer inevitable. Read your own memo looking for the answer you were clearly fishing for.

Step 5: Set a Decision Deadline and Put It in the Calendar

Deadlines only work when they are real. This means a calendar entry, a reminder, and a stated consequence.

Example: "I will decide on the vendor by Thursday at 4pm. At that time I will send the contract to legal, whichever option is chosen." Now Thursday at 4pm is not a moment of reflection. It is a moment of execution.

If Thursday arrives and you still feel stuck, you do not extend. You pick the option you would least regret, or you pick the option that is easiest to reverse, and you move. In most cases, the cost of choosing the slightly weaker of two reasonable options is far less than the cost of two more weeks of indecision.

A useful fallback: if the two options are close enough that you genuinely cannot choose, they are close enough that either will do. That is not a cop-out. That is accurate. Say it out loud and move on.

Step 6: Commit Out Loud

Commitment is a behavior, not a feeling. You have permission to commit before you feel confident. In fact, that is the normal order of operations for most of the decisive people I work with.

Three ways to make a decision stick:

  • Say it to someone who will remember. Tell your business partner, your spouse, your team. "I have decided to go with the smaller launch." Naming it publicly closes the loop.
  • Take one irreversible action within 24 hours. Sign the document, send the email, cancel the other option. If your decision requires a reversible step first, take that step anyway.
  • Write down what you expect to happen. Two sentences. "I expect delivery in six weeks and a 15 percent cost saving." Then you have a way to review the decision on its merits later, rather than on how it felt at the time.

Step 7: Review Once, on a Date You Chose in Advance

Set the review date when you make the decision, not after the resentment builds up. Thirty days for a monthly-cycle decision. Ninety days for a strategy or hire. Twelve months for a career move or a big bet.

At review, ask three questions and write the answers down:

  • Given what I knew at the time, was the reasoning sound?
  • What information has changed?
  • Do I stay, adjust, or reverse?

The first question protects your confidence. A decision can be well reasoned and still produce a poor outcome. If you do not separate those two things, you will lose faith in your judgment and slow down on every future call. That is how one bad quarter turns into chronic hesitation.

This is also where a coach is genuinely useful. Not to choose for you, but to hold the review date, ask the uncomfortable question, and notice the pattern of where you tend to stall. I see the same pattern recur across a whole quarter, which is information you usually cannot see from inside your own week.

A Worked Example

Here is how the full process looks, using an invented scenario for illustration.

Middle Eastern man in traditional attire working on a laptop in a modern office setting.

A consultant with a small team is deciding whether to take on a large client that would consume most of her capacity for four months. She has been going back and forth for three weeks.

Sort: Hard to reverse, high cost. It locks her team for a season. Two weeks is permitted. But note that three weeks have already passed, so the budget is spent.

Name it: "I am deciding whether to accept the Chen engagement by Friday, and I will judge success by whether it covers fixed costs without requiring me to cancel my two smaller retainer clients."

Memo: The binding criterion is margin, not revenue. Doing nothing is a legitimate option because her pipeline is not empty. The cost of waiting is moderate: the client has another firm in mind, so a slow answer is an answer.

Two people: Her operations lead, who knows the capacity math. A peer from a mastermind group, who does not. The peer asks the sharpest question: "If this client covers costs with almost no margin, what are you actually buying?" The answer is stability, and she realizes that is not worth four months of capacity.

Deadline: Thursday at noon, one day early, to give the client time to plan.

Commit: She calls the client, declines the full engagement and counters with a narrower scope. The counter is an option she had not written in her original memo, and it emerged because she clarified the criterion first.

Review: Set for 60 days out to check whether the narrower scope is working and whether the freed capacity is being used well.

Notice that speed did not mean a rushed yes. It meant she got to a real decision, and a better third option, in four days instead of four more weeks.

What to Do If You Are Still Stuck

If you have run the memo and set the date and are still circling, one of these is usually true.

You are protecting a feeling, not a value

You are not afraid of a bad outcome. You are afraid of feeling the discomfort of being wrong. Name that out loud. It takes the sting out and puts the decision back in the realm of business.

You have not accepted the trade

Every real decision costs you something. If you are trying to find the option where you get all of the upside and none of the cost, you will search forever, because that option does not exist. Choose the cost you are willing to pay.

The decision is too big to make alone

Some decisions carry enough weight that the honest move is structured support: a thinking partner, a coach, a mentor. That is not weakness. That is matching your resources to the size of the call, which is exactly what the first step in this process asks you to do.

Start With the One on Your Mind Right Now

You know which decision it is. It has been with you for a while.

Here is your next hour. Set the timer. Write the sentence. Answer the six prompts. Email two people the question about where your reasoning is weakest. Put the decision date in the calendar with the word "decide" in the title.

Then decide on time, and let the review date be where you learn. The people I work with who build real confidence do not build it by making fewer decisions. They build it by closing decisions cleanly, reviewing them honestly, and discovering that they can trust themselves to handle what comes next.

Clarity is not something you wait for. It is something you produce, one closed loop at a time.

Share

More articles

The Two-Calendar Method: How to Protect Work-Life Balance Without Dropping the Ball

Most work-life balance advice fails because it treats balance as a feeling you find, not a structure you build. The Two-Calendar Method is a practical framework for busy professionals and entrepreneurs: one calendar for commitments, one for capacity. Here is how to set it up in a single working session and keep it honest.

Nov 15, 2026
The Two-Calendar Method: How to Protect Work-Life Balance Without Dropping the Ball

7 Confidence Mistakes Busy Professionals Make (And the Exact Fixes That Work)

You are not short on confidence. You are short on a system for using it under pressure. Here are seven confidence mistakes busy professionals make, with concrete corrections you can apply this week.

Nov 15, 2026
7 Confidence Mistakes Busy Professionals Make (And the Exact Fixes That Work)
Start Your Journey

Ready to get started?

Book a Free Call

T&L Custom &Strategic Solutions

Strategic coaching for professionals and entrepreneurs.

The work Engagements T&L Contact Client sign in

© 2026 T&L Custom &Strategic Solutions. All conversations confidential.

Powered by Coachful